Preservationists want to save Gulf Street house from demolition

A sign in front of this historic home at 250 Gulf Street states that it is scheduled for demolition.
A sign in front of this historic home at 250 Gulf Street states that it is scheduled for demolition.

The Milford Preservation Trust is taking the lead in attempting to save an historic Gulf Street house slated for demolition.

The home is the Elijah Bryan House, built about 1790, and located at 250 Gulf Street. The current owner applied for a demolition permit in June, and Milford’s city historian imposed a 90-day delay on the demolition, which provides a short window of time for concerned parties to seek out alternative solutions, such as finding a buyer for the house.

Former City Historian Richard Platt said the house is significant because of its architecture, which is a Dutch half gambrel, similar to the Sanford-Bristol house on North Street that was saved from demolition at the beginning of the year.

“It’s one of six historically significant houses in Milford,” Platt said. “Three of them are on Gulf Street.”

The Sanford-Bristol house had a couple of things going for it that the Elijah Bryan house doesn’t, and those could prove significant, according to preservationists who want to save it.

This sign on the front of the house reads 'Circa 1790 Elijah Bryan'
This sign on the front of the house reads ‘Circa 1790 Elijah Bryan’

The Sanford-Bristol house was located in a city historic district. Gulf Street is not an historic district, though ironically a group has been working to have it designated as one.

Also, the Sanford-Bristol house was listed on at least one historic register, and the Elijah Bryan house is not.

“The only option is to appeal to the homeowner,” Platt said.

According to city records, the house was owned by the late Donald and June Poland. A demolition sign in front of the house says it is now owned by the couple’s son, Lance Poland, who has not yet been reached for comment.

Although one of the preservationists trying to save the house said the owner wants to raze the house due to its condition, city records show that the house and property appraised at $351,000 last year. Also, Platt said he’s been told that the late owners kept it in good condition.

Historic district

“One of the reasons there is so little anyone can do about the demolition is that we don’t have an historic district designation along Gulf Street,” said Alice Oliver, who is chairing a committee to establish it as an historic district. “If we had an historic district here, it could have legally prevented the demolition. But we don’t, because residents along the Gulf Street corridor are not overwhelmingly in favor of establishing one.”

Milford Preservation Trust President Michele Kramer is expected to hold a meeting this week to talk more about what can be done to save the house.

Lance Poland, homeowner, applied for demolition on June 26, due to the “current condition” of the house, Kramer said. Milford’s new city historian, Carol LaBrake, imposed a 90-day delay on the demolition after being notified about the plans to raze it. That delay runs out Sept. 28.

Time, therefore, is running out, she and others said.

Kramer said the house at 234 Gulf Street is also in jeopardy; it is currently owned by a bank.

The house at 234 Gulf Street also dates back to 1790.

“So there is a lot of work to be done,” Kramer said.

Platt said preservationists were lucky with the Sanford-Bristol house because “an angel” — resident Lesley Mills — stepped forward to buy it and restore it.

Platt is hoping for another angel to save the Elijah Bryan house.

Facebook Comments

6 thoughts on “Preservationists want to save Gulf Street house from demolition”

  1. I have admired this home for years and it is a pivotal piece of Milford history. I hope Mr. Poland will reconsider and restore this treasure – or sell it to someone will. And if the decision is made to sell – put forth the effort to effectively market the property this time – complete with a detailed description photos highlighting the historic elements which I know still exist. DEMOLITION IS NOT AN OPTION – IT IS A CHOICE.

  2. I am deeply upset that Lance and June Poland plan to demolish the home
    Mr. Poland’s parents owned and loved, the historic Elijah Bryan House,
    c.1790.This beautiful example of 18th century architecture is one of only 18
    period homes left in Milford – and Milford was a thriving, pivotal
    colonial-era town.

    Mr. Poland claims the current condition of the home requires demolition
    – even though his parents maintained the home up until their death a few years
    ago. Milford Preservation Trust offered to absorb the cost for a historic
    home assessment by a qualified professional – to which the Polands have
    NOT responded. What are they afraid of?

    The Polands may say they tried to sell the home but received no offers.
    Yes, the home was listed for sale for a short time – no description, no
    pictures -–no effort to sell. DEMOLITION IS A CHOICE, not a necessity. It will
    take far less money to restore the present structure than to demolish and build
    a new home in its place. I understand the Poland’s daughter will live in
    a newly-built home on the property. One can only assume the fond
    memories from visiting Grandma and Grandpa’s home – I cannot understand my they would want to demolish their legacy and Milford’s history.

    New homes can and are easily duplicated anywhere. Historic treasures, such
    as 250 Gulf Street, cannot be replicated. Once it is gone, it is lost

    I am praying for a last-minute reprieve and that the Polands will
    reconsider this shortsighted decision to deprive their family of their history
    and by extension, Milford’s history.

    Gwen Bruno
    Milford, CT

  3. Unfortunately Gwen, if it had pictures of the dwelling, that would have hindered the ability to sell, more than hurt it. There were over 50 showings, the house was listed at a low price and not one written offer was conveyed. There should be no burden on the homeowner to reach into their own pocket to renovate a home that is in such deplorable condition, it is dangerous. The asbestos, termite damage, rot and mold in this property should not have been conveyed as a selling point in pictures. Additionally, the former homeowners, one who has been deceased for a few years now were elderly and could not afford to keep up with this home. The only short sided ones are the ones who did not know the facts and instead go to the press with their uneducated views.

  4. They tried for 13 months to sell it, if you wanted it so badly, you could have written a check. This article states it was appraised at 350k, they were willing to take just 200k, that shows how bad it really was and no one looked at facts, just wrote an opinion based article. You don’t even know what you are talking about to say Lance and June Poland are demolishing the house, June was one of the deceased owners who passed several years ago. Next time you take up a cause, just have a slight clue about what you are talking about! Then you call a house their legacy, they were both over 80 and didn’t live there even close to the majority of their lives! This is not a short sided reprieve at all, why should they continue to pay taxes on the house and property that is unliveable and beyond repair? If they waited any longer the house would have fallen over on it’s own anyway. At this point, now that it is down, maybe you can get ahold of the crew and gather together some of the old rotted wood and asbestos for a nice keepsake since clearly you are in love. Then it also won’t be lost forever and maybe you can have a new home built with the termite infested wood!!!

Leave a Comment